Is Bird Shot Good For Home Defense

As a firearms expert, I have been asked numerous times about the effectiveness of bird shot as a home defense ammunition. The argument in favor of using birdshot for self-defense is that it will not over-penetrate and potentially harm innocent bystanders or damage property, while still providing enough stopping power to neutralize an intruder.

However, there are several factors to consider before deciding on birdshot as your primary choice for home defense. In this article, we will examine the characteristics of birdshot and its suitability for self-defense situations. We will also explore alternative options and compare them to the advantages and disadvantages of birdshot. Ultimately, the decision regarding which type of ammunition to use depends on individual circumstances, personal preferences, training level, and legal considerations.

Understanding Home Defense Ammunition

Home defense is a crucial aspect of protecting oneself and one’s family. When it comes to selecting the best ammunition for home defense, there are several factors to consider. Shotguns and pistols are popular options, but each has its advantages and disadvantages.

Shotguns have been a favorite choice for home defense due to their ability to inflict significant damage on an intruder at close range with minimal aiming required. This means that even those who lack experience in firearms can effectively use them. On the other hand, pistols provide greater accuracy and higher magazine capacity but require more skill to handle effectively.

When it comes to shotgun ammunition types, there are several options available, including birdshot, buckshot, and slugs. Birdshot consists of small pellets designed mainly for hunting birds or small game animals. Its limited penetration power makes it less effective for self-defense purposes as it lacks stopping power against an attacker wearing heavy clothing or body armor.

In contrast, buckshot contains larger projectiles that can penetrate deeper into the target, making it suitable for self-defense situations where multiple attackers may be present. Slugs consist of a single projectile designed specifically for maximum penetration against hard targets like walls or doors.

Understanding the different types of shotgun ammunition is critical when deciding which type will suit your specific needs. In the subsequent section, we will explore the purpose of birdshot in-home defense scenarios further.

The Purpose Of Birdshot

Birdshot is a shotgun shell loaded with small shot pellets used for hunting and other non-lethal purposes. The range of a birdshot is limited, typically not exceeding 20 yards, and its stopping power is limited due to the size and weight of the shot pellets. Birdshot is not recommended for home defense due to its limited range and stopping power, as an intruder may still be able to continue their threat even after being hit with birdshot. Birdshot is best suited for hunting, pest control, and other non-lethal applications. While birdshot is not recommended for home defense, it is still a viable option for certain situations. Alternatives to birdshot for home defense include buckshot and slugs, which have greater range and stopping power.

Non-Lethal Usage

When considering the purpose of birdshot, one subtopic that often arises is its potential use as a non-lethal option for home defense. While using birdshot in this way may seem less lethal than traditional ammunition, it still poses significant risks and ethical considerations.

Non-lethal options such as birdshot are often employed when individuals want to protect their homes but do not wish to take a life. However, it’s important to remember that even though birdshot pellets are smaller, they can still cause serious injury or death depending on the range and location of impact. Additionally, while birdshot may be effective at close range, it loses accuracy and stopping power at longer distances.

When considering the ethical implications of utilizing non-lethal options like birdshot for home defense purposes, there are several factors to consider. Is the individual willing to potentially injure or kill an intruder if necessary? Are they prepared to face legal consequences if their actions result in harm? These questions must be carefully considered before making any decisions about what type of ammunition to use for home defense.

In conclusion, while birdshot may appear to be a less lethal option for protecting oneself and loved ones from intruders, it still carries significant risks and ethical considerations. It’s crucial that individuals weigh all possibilities before deciding on what type of ammunition best suits their needs. Ultimately, safety should always come first when handling firearms or other weapons.

Range Limitations

When it comes to discussing the purpose of birdshot, another critical subtopic is its range limitations. While birdshot may be effective at close ranges, it loses accuracy and stopping power as the distance increases. This limitation also applies to indoor settings where there are tight spaces that can limit a shooter’s maneuverability.

In terms of ammunition selection for home defense purposes, individuals must consider not only the potential harm they might inflict but also their own safety. The range limitations of birdshot make it unsuitable for use in larger homes or outdoor environments where greater distances between an intruder and defender could occur. In such situations, more potent rounds would be necessary.

The effectiveness of birdshot depends on many factors beyond just its range limitations. Pellet size, density, and velocity all play significant roles in determining how much damage each round will do upon impact with its target. Additionally, shooters must consider how these pellets spread when fired from shotguns since wider patterns reduce accuracy even further.

To summarize, the range limitations of birdshot should be considered by anyone selecting it for home defense purposes carefully. Its effectiveness is limited to shorter distances making it suitable mainly for smaller homes or confined areas like hallways and staircases. Shooters need to ensure they choose ammunition capable of dealing with any situation while considering the ethical implications surrounding protection against possible intruders without causing undue harm if possible.

Stopping Power

When discussing the purpose of birdshot, stopping power is an essential subtopic that must be considered. Stopping power refers to a shotgun’s ability to immediately incapacitate or stop an attacker upon impact with its target. The effectiveness of this feature depends on various factors such as shot placement and psychological effect.

Shot placement plays a crucial role in determining the stopping power of birdshot. Hitting vital organs like the heart or lungs will likely result in immediate incapacitation, while hitting non-vital areas may not have the same effect. Additionally, firing multiple rounds at different locations can increase the chance of hitting vital organs and causing more damage.

The psychological effect of being hit by birdshot can also contribute to its stopping power. An intruder who realizes they have been shot may experience shock and fear, making them less aggressive and easier to apprehend. However, it is important to note that this effect varies among individuals and cannot always be relied upon.

In conclusion, when selecting birdshot for home defense purposes, one must consider its stopping power alongside other factors such as range limitations. Shot placement and psychological effects are two critical components that determine how effective each round will be at stopping an attacker. Shooters should ensure they choose ammunition capable of dealing with any situation while minimizing harm if possible.

Characteristics Of Birdshot

The Purpose of Birdshot, as discussed in the previous section, is to provide a wider spread pattern when fired from a shotgun. This leads many people to believe that birdshot would be an excellent choice for home defense. However, before we dive into the characteristics of birdshot, let’s make one thing clear: using any firearm for self-defense should always be a last resort.

That being said, it’s important to understand what you’re working with if you do choose to use a shotgun loaded with birdshot for home defense. The pellet size in birdshot shells typically ranges from #9 (the smallest) to #2 (the largest). This means that there are multiple pellets within each shell and they can vary in size.

Some characteristics of birdshot include its lower recoil compared to other types of shotgun ammunition. Additionally, since there are multiple pellets per shot, chances are higher that at least one will hit your target. However, while this may sound like a benefit, it can also pose some serious problems in terms of penetration power and stopping power.

When considering whether or not birdshot is good for home defense purposes, it’s crucial to take into account factors such as distance between yourself and the attacker(s), potential collateral damage from missed shots or over-penetration through walls, and the specific type of load used. As with all firearms and ammunition choices, research and practice are key components in making informed decisions about personal safety.

  • Factors affecting effectiveness of birdshot loads:
  • Distance between shooter/target
  • Pellet size/load type
  • Potential for over-penetration/collateral damage
  • Shooter proficiency/training
  • Specific circumstances/situation

Stopping power: how effective is birdshot? While some argue that larger pellet sizes increase stopping power due to their ability to cause more tissue damage upon impact, others point out that smaller pellets have better spread patterns which increases the chance of hitting a vital area. Ultimately, the effectiveness of birdshot for stopping an attacker will depend on multiple factors including pellet size and velocity, distance from target, and shot placement. It’s important to consider all of these variables when choosing ammunition for self-defense purposes.

Stopping Power: How Effective Is Birdshot?

Birdshot, when used in defense scenarios, is a controversial topic due to its performance in ballistic testing. In order to evaluate its stopping power effectively, a comparison between birdshot and buckshot is necessary. Ballistically, birdshot is ideal for close range defensive scenarios due to its increased pellet spread. However, at further distances, it does not perform as well as buckshot. When tested, birdshot was found to be less effective at penetration with a lower degree of incapacitation. Comparatively, buckshot was found to have superior penetration and incapacitation properties. Thus, birdshot is suitable for home defense scenarios at short distances, but it is not as effective as buckshot at longer distances.

Birdshot Stopping Power

When it comes to home defense, choosing the right firearm and ammunition is essential. Shotguns are a popular choice for their versatility and power. However, there has been much debate about whether birdshot is an effective option for stopping an intruder.

Birdshot is designed for small game hunting and consists of small pellets that spread out from the shotgun barrel in a wide pattern. While this makes it effective at hitting moving targets, its terminal ballistics may not be sufficient for self-defense purposes. The individual pellets do not penetrate deeply enough into the target to cause significant damage to vital organs or stop an attacker’s advance.

Additionally, the use of shotgun spread can increase the chance of collateral damage in close quarters situations such as those encountered in home defense scenarios. This makes it important to consider the safety of other occupants in adjacent rooms or apartments before using birdshot as a defensive measure.

In conclusion, while birdshot may seem like a viable option due to its ability to hit moving targets with ease, it lacks the necessary stopping power required for self-defense situations. Shotgun spreads also pose a risk of causing unintended harm, making them less suitable than other types of ammunition specifically designed for home defense purposes. In order to ensure maximum effectiveness and minimal danger, homeowners should choose appropriate firearms and ammunition after careful consideration and research.

Ballistic Testing

Shotguns and handguns are two of the most popular choices for home defense firearms. However, there is much debate over which one is more effective in stopping an intruder. One aspect that should be taken into consideration when comparing these two types of firearms is their respective distance vs accuracy capabilities.

In terms of distance, shotguns have a shorter effective range than handguns due to their wider spread pattern. This means that at longer distances, the pellets from birdshot may not hit the intended target with enough force to stop them. On the other hand, handguns offer greater accuracy at longer ranges and can deliver higher velocity rounds with more penetrating power.

When it comes to testing ballistic performance, many experts use gelatin blocks as a substitute for human tissue. Testing has shown that while birdshot can cause significant surface damage to soft tissue targets such as organs or muscle groups, its penetration depth is limited compared to other types of ammunition designed specifically for self-defense purposes.

Therefore, while shotgun spreads may seem like a good choice because they increase your chances of hitting a moving target in close quarters situations, this advantage must be weighed against their decreased effectiveness at longer distances and lower terminal ballistics. In conclusion, homeowners should carefully consider all factors before choosing between shotgun or handgun for home defense purposes and conduct proper research on various types of ammunition available for each firearm type.

Birdshot Vs Buckshot

Moving on to the subtopic of birdshot vs. buckshot in regards to stopping power, it is important to understand the differences between these two shotgun shell types. Birdshot typically consists of small pellets (usually around .08 inches) and has a wide spread pattern, making it effective at short ranges for hunting small game such as birds or rabbits. Buckshot, on the other hand, contains larger pellets (usually around .32 inches), fewer in number than birdshot and with less spread.

When considering self-defense situations, many people wonder if birdshot can be an effective choice for stopping intruders. Testing has shown that while birdshot may cause significant surface damage to soft tissue targets, its penetration depth is limited compared to buckshot or other types of ammunition designed specifically for self-defense purposes.

In fact, some law enforcement agencies have stopped using birdshot entirely due to its lack of effectiveness against human targets. While it may seem like a good option because of its wider spread accuracy in close quarters situations and reduced risk of overpenetration beyond walls, homeowners should carefully consider their intended purpose before choosing between birdshot or buckshot for home defense purposes.

Ultimately, when it comes to stopping power and effectiveness in self-defense scenarios, our recommendation would be to choose buckshot over birdshot due to its increased terminal ballistics and deeper penetration capabilities. However, as always with firearms choices, there are multiple factors that must be taken into account such as range limitations within your living space and recoil management abilities among others; therefore careful consideration should be given before deciding which type of shotgun shell will best suit one’s needs for home defense purposes.

Over-Penetration Risks

When considering the use of birdshot for home defense, it is important to assess the risks that come with over-penetration. Over-penetration occurs when a bullet or shot pellet passes through an intended target and continues on its path, potentially hitting unintended objects or people. In a home defense scenario, this could mean endangering loved ones or neighbors in adjacent rooms or homes.

Birdshot pellets are generally smaller than other types of shotgun ammunition and have less energy behind them. This means they are more likely to stop inside the body of an attacker rather than passing through them and continuing their trajectory. However, there is still a risk of over-penetration depending on factors such as distance from the shooter, type of firearm used, and barriers between the shooter and target.

To minimize over-penetration risks with birdshot, it is crucial to conduct a thorough damage assessment of potential targets before using any weapon. Consider the layout of your home and identify safe zones where you can shoot without risking harm to others. Additionally, choose appropriate firearms and ammunition based on your particular situation; consult with experts if necessary.

In summary, while birdshot may offer some advantages in terms of reduced penetration likelihood compared to other forms of ammunition like buckshot or slugs, it should not be relied upon solely for home defense without careful consideration given to over-penetration risks. A comprehensive damage assessment must be conducted beforehand so that you can make informed decisions about how best to protect yourself and those around you.

As we move forward discussing alternatives to birdshot for home defense purposes, it is worth noting that all options must be evaluated through a similar lens – weighing both effectiveness against attackers versus safety concerns for innocent bystanders.

Alternatives To Birdshot

Buckshot is a type of shotgun ammunition, consisting of multiple pellets that are fired in a single shot, and is often used for hunting and self-defense purposes. Slug is a single, large lead projectile that is fired from a shotgun and is a more effective choice for long range shooting. Pepper spray and mace are non-lethal, aerosolized irritants that can be used to temporarily incapacitate a person in close-range. Non-lethal ammunition, such as rubber bullets, bean bags, and blanks, are also options for home defense with less lethal consequences.

Buckshot

When considering alternatives to birdshot for home defense, one option that often comes up is buckshot. Buckshot refers to shotgun shells loaded with larger pellets, typically between 8 and 00 in size. These pellets have a wider spread pattern than birdshot, which can increase the likelihood of hitting an intruder in close quarters.

The pellet size of buckshot provides significant stopping power at close range. When fired from a short-barreled shotgun, it has been known to cause serious injury or death even without direct hits on vital organs. Additionally, the wide spread pattern allows for greater margin of error when aiming under duress.

However, there are some limitations to using buckshot for home defense. The range limitations of buckshot is a concern as its effectiveness drops significantly beyond 15 yards due to the rapid loss of kinetic energy over distance and decreased accuracy caused by increased shot dispersion. Moreover, recoil from firing heavy loads may be too much for some shooters to handle effectively.

In conclusion, while buckshot offers advantages over birdshot in terms of stopping power and spread pattern consistency, it also presents certain drawbacks like limited effective range and considerable recoil. It’s important for homeowners looking into this alternative round to understand both its pros and cons before making a decision based on their specific needs and abilities as a shooter.

Slug

Moving on from buckshot, another alternative to consider for home defense is slug ammunition. A shotgun slug refers to a single, large projectile that is fired from a shotgun barrel. Unlike birdshot and buckshot, which consist of multiple smaller pellets, slugs offer greater accuracy over longer distances due to their singular trajectory.

Compared to buckshot, slugs are heavier and have more kinetic energy upon impact. This means they can cause even greater damage to an intruder at close range than buckshot would. However, the downside is that the lack of shot dispersion also means that missed shots may be more dangerous if they penetrate through walls or other barriers.

While slug accuracy can be better than buckshot at longer ranges, it still has limitations compared to traditional firearms like rifles or pistols. Beyond approximately 50 yards, the drop in velocity and increase in bullet drop becomes significant enough that hitting targets accurately becomes difficult without specialized equipment such as scopes or sights.

In conclusion, while slug rounds offer increased accuracy and stopping power compared to birdshot and buckshot alternatives when used within its effective range, it should not be relied on as a primary weapon for long-range engagements. As with all firearm choices for home defense, careful consideration should be given based on individual needs and capabilities before making a decision.

Buckshot: An Effective Alternative?

While birdshot is a popular choice for hunting birds and small game, it may not be the best option for home defense. In fact, according to statistics from the FBI, birdshot only penetrates an average of 8-10 inches into tissue at close range. This means that while it may cause significant pain and injury to an intruder, it may not stop them in their tracks.

Shotguns are often considered one of the most effective weapons for self-defense due to their versatility and stopping power. However, when comparing shotgun vs handgun options for home defense, it’s important to consider factors such as accuracy and maneuverability. While shotguns can deliver a wide spray of projectiles with buckshot or birdshot loads, they can also be heavy and difficult to control in tight spaces.

Buckshot is another common type of shotgun ammunition used for self-defense. Unlike birdshot, buckshot consists of larger pellets that penetrate deeper into tissue upon impact. Buckshot provides more stopping power than birdshot but still allows for some degree of spread, making it ideal for engaging multiple targets or hitting moving targets.

A slug is yet another alternative to consider when choosing between buckshot vs slug ammo types. Slugs are essentially large bullets that offer exceptional penetration and accuracy over longer distances. They’re commonly used by hunters who need greater knockdown power than what birdshot or buckshot can provide.

When considering the best ammunition for home defense purposes, there are many factors to take into account such as accuracy, recoil management, terminal ballistics among others; however hollow point ammunition could be a good compromise since it offers excellent expansion upon impact without causing excessive damage beyond your target area which makes this specially designed bullet perfect if you want something powerful enough to protect yourself while minimizing risks associated with collateral damage caused by stray rounds or over-penetration issues seen with other types of ammunition on the market today.

Hollow Point Ammunition

When it comes to ammunition for home defense, there are many factors to consider. One popular option is jacketed hollow point (JHP) ammunition, which is designed to expand upon impact and transfer more energy into the target. This can be particularly effective in stopping an intruder while minimizing over-penetration that could harm innocent bystanders or damage property.

To understand how JHPs work, ballistic gel testing is often used. In this test, a block of special gelatin is shot with the bullet and then examined to see how deep and wide the wound channel is. The goal is typically to achieve a penetration depth of around 12 inches, which has been shown to effectively stop an attacker in most cases.

There are some potential downsides to using JHPs, however. For one thing, they may not penetrate as deeply as other types of ammo, such as full metal jacket rounds. Additionally, because JHPs are designed specifically for self-defense situations, they tend to cost more than other types of ammo.

Ultimately, whether or not you choose JHP ammunition will depend on your personal preferences and situation. It’s important to keep legal considerations in mind when selecting any type of home defense ammo – something we’ll explore further in the next section about legal considerations for home defense ammunition.

Legal Considerations For Home Defense Ammunition

Transition from Previous Section:
As we have seen, hollow point ammunition is an effective option for self-defense situations. However, choosing the right ammunition for your situation involves considering more than just its effectiveness in stopping a threat. Legal implications must also be taken into account when selecting home defense ammunition.

Legal Considerations for Home Defense Ammunition:

When it comes to protecting our homes and loved ones, most of us will do whatever it takes to ensure their safety. While having firearms for this purpose may be legal in some states or countries, there are still laws that govern what type of ammunition can be used for self-defense purposes. It is important to understand these legal implications before making any decisions about which ammunition you should use.

One crucial factor to consider is whether your state has strict liability laws regarding self-defense shootings. In such cases, if someone is injured or killed during a shooting incident regardless of intent or circumstances, the shooter could face criminal charges and civil lawsuits. Using certain types of ammunition that are deemed excessive or unnecessary by law enforcement officials could potentially increase these risks.

Another consideration when selecting home defense ammunition is how well it will perform in your particular environment. For example, birdshot may not penetrate walls as easily as other types of rounds but might not provide enough stopping power against an attacker at close range. Similarly, using military-grade ammo designed for combat situations could result in overpenetration that puts innocent bystanders at risk.

Choosing the Right Ammunition:

Ultimately, choosing the right ammunition for your specific situation requires careful consideration of both its effectiveness and potential legal implications. Consult with local law enforcement officials or experienced firearms experts who can help guide you through this decision-making process based on your unique needs and circumstances. Remember that while stopping a threat quickly is essential in a self-defense scenario, doing so legally and responsibly should always remain paramount concerns when selecting home defense ammunition.

Choosing The Right Ammunition For Your Situation

Ammunition comparison is a crucial aspect of firearm ownership. When selecting ammunition, it’s essential to consider the intended use and match the correct type with your situation. For home defense scenarios, the right choice can make all the difference between life and death.

When it comes to choosing ammunition for home defense situations, many factors come into play. One popular option is birdshot, which typically consists of small pellets that disperse upon firing. However, while birdshot may be effective at close range against birds or small animals, it may not be an ideal choice for self-defense purposes.

The main issue with birdshot as self-defense ammunition is its lack of penetration power. Birdshot does not penetrate deeply enough to reach vital organs in humans effectively. Additionally, since most incidents occur in low light conditions, accuracy becomes even more important. The spread pattern of birdshot makes hitting specific areas challenging.

In conclusion, when comparing ammunition types for home defense scenarios, there are better options than birdshot available on the market today. Consider using hollow point rounds designed specifically for personal protection instead. These rounds offer superior penetration power while minimizing over-penetration risks associated with full metal jacketed rounds. Remember always to ensure you choose the proper caliber and train regularly to develop proficiency with your chosen ammunition type and firearm combination.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Birdshot Be Used In Any Type Of Shotgun?

Shotgun compatibility is a crucial consideration when selecting the right ammunition for home defense. Birdshot, with its smaller pellets and wider spread pattern, may be compatible with various types of shotguns depending on their gauge and barrel length. However, effectiveness comparison between birdshot and other types of shotgun loads such as buckshot or slugs should also be taken into account. It is important to note that while birdshot may cause significant harm at close range, it may not penetrate deeply enough to stop an intruder in some situations. Therefore, careful evaluation of both shotgun compatibility and effectiveness is necessary before deciding on using birdshot for home defense purposes.

What Is The Recommended Distance For Using Birdshot In A Home Defense Situation?

When considering the use of birdshot in a home defense situation, it is important to understand its effective range and shotgun spread. The recommended distance for using birdshot in a confined space such as a home would be within 7-10 yards. Beyond this distance, the pellets will begin to lose their effectiveness and may not penetrate deeply enough to stop an attacker. Additionally, the spread of the shot can increase significantly at greater distances, potentially endangering innocent bystanders or damaging property. It is crucial for individuals who choose to use birdshot for home defense to receive proper training on safe and effective usage of their firearm.

Will Birdshot Cause Damage To Walls Or Furniture In A Home?

When considering the use of birdshot for home defense, it is important to assess its potential impact on wall and furniture damage. Birdshot has a lower penetration power compared to other types of ammunition, which could result in decreased property damage when used inside a confined space like a home. However, this also means that birdshot may not have the stopping power necessary to effectively neutralize an intruder. In terms of furniture damage, birdshot can still cause harm as it disperses upon impacting surfaces, potentially leading to unwanted collateral damage. As such, while birdshot may be suitable for certain situations where minimizing wall damage is essential, careful consideration should be given to factors such as desired stopping power and risk of unintended consequences before making a decision on using it for home defense purposes.

Is Birdshot More Affordable Than Other Types Of Home Defense Ammunition?

When considering ammunition for home defense, it is important to weigh the benefits and drawbacks of various options. One aspect that may factor into a decision is affordability. In terms of birdshot availability, it can be found at most ammunition retailers and generally costs less than other types of home defense rounds. However, when it comes to birdshot effectiveness as a self-defense round, opinions vary. While some argue that its spread pattern can increase the likelihood of hitting an intruder in close range situations, others contend that birdshot lacks the stopping power necessary to immediately incapacitate an attacker. Ultimately, individuals should carefully evaluate their personal needs and preferences before selecting any type of ammunition for home defense purposes.

Can Birdshot Be Used For Hunting In Addition To Home Defense?

As the saying goes, "killing two birds with one stone" is a phrase that applies to using birdshot for hunting and home defense. However, while it may be effective against small game such as quail or pheasant, its effectiveness against different types of intruders remains debatable. Birdshot’s smaller pellets have less penetration power compared to other forms of ammunition and may not stop an attacker in their tracks. As a firearms/weapons expert, I would recommend selecting ammunition specifically designed for home defense purposes rather than relying solely on birdshot for protection.

Conclusion

When it comes to home defense, the type of ammunition used can be a matter of life or death. Birdshot may seem like a viable option due to its affordability and widespread availability, but is it truly effective in this scenario?

While birdshot can technically be used in any shotgun, it is not recommended for home defense situations. The pellets are small and do not penetrate deeply enough to stop an attacker. Additionally, at distances over 10 feet, the spread becomes too wide and accuracy decreases significantly.

Furthermore, birdshot has a high potential for collateral damage. It can easily cause harm to walls or furniture within a home, putting innocent individuals at risk. In contrast, there are other types of ammunition specifically designed for home defense that offer better stopping power with less chance of causing unintended destruction.

It’s ironic that some people would choose to use birdshot – typically thought of as a hunting round – for self-defense purposes when there are more suitable options available on the market. At the end of the day, investing in reliable ammunition could mean the difference between life and death in a dangerous situation. Don’t let cost or convenience outweigh safety when choosing ammunition for your home defense needs.

Leave a Reply